How to read a resume : uncovering the context behind the paper
In a prior White Paper I discussed how to write a good resume. It turned out to be a very popular White Paper and we received a lot of positive feedback from it. It definitely presented a unique point of view on how a resume should be crafted, especially because of my introduction on why I like to read obituaries (it’s not as macabre as it sounds, thankfully).
And while that was an interesting topic to cover, I want to focus on the other side of the resume this time—a White Paper geared towards employers, managers and executives – the people who the read resumes and make the decisions on who to call and who to pass on.
My intent is to provide some context for how an employer reads a resume. In an average day for me, I scan 50+ resumes and thoroughly read 10 or more of them. Multiply that by 30 years and I have seen a heck of a lot of resumes.
Most managers read a resume in depth and analyze it. They look at every sentence and try to get as much info from it as possible. That makes sense. After all, what manager wants to waste time interviewing someone who can’t do their job?
However, every word has a context. It is easy to miss the forest for the trees. This White Paper will give some examples of things to be aware of when evaluating a prospective employee’s resume. It will help you visualize the person behind the paper.
I can break the parts of a resume down into a few areas:
JOB HOPPERS
Every once in a while I send a client a resume of someone who has frequently changed jobs over a period of a few years. Often, when we go over resumes on the phone, I will hear “Wow, this person is a job hopper.” This is the perfect example of context in a resume.
Here are two things to look for in this situation:
- What was happening in the economy at that time?Someone with 3 jobs between 2008 and 2010 may just be a victim of a lousy economy. Imagine being good at your job and being laid off with the rest of the world in 2008 and scrambling to stay employed. There are periods in the economy when you can make all the right decisions and just be in the wrong place at the wrong time. Someone with a spotty history between 2008 and 2010 with a stable background both before and after may just be a victim of circumstances. That could have been anyone. That could have been you.
- Gaps between jobsOne thing to look for is, how long did it take for someone to find work? In this situation, you are looking for a pattern. Someone who was out of work only once for 9 months but has shown consistent employment before and after may have been taking care of a sick relative. That person may warrant further exploration. The flip side is, of course, a resume in which every job change contains a 6 month gap before starting a new job. That is not a good pattern.
PROMOTIONS
Promotions and title changes are hidden signs that can mean a lot and are often ignored.
Consider a resume from someone who has had 15 years of experience spread over 2 different employers for a key job on your team. The candidate has had at least 7 years of experience with two different companies and seems to have had job stability. Look for one thing—have they ever been promoted? If yes, that is good. If no, that brings up the question—why have two different companies not thought enough of this person to promote him or her during 7 years of employment? The answer may be benign but it is still a question worth answering.
Also, don’t confuse a meaningless title increase with a promotion. Going from Engineer 1 to Engineer 2 is not a promotion. It is a way to keep an employee in a salary band.
Of course there is the other side of the coin. Consider someone with 15 years of experience with 4 different companies. At 3 of the 4 companies, despite being there for no more than 4 years, the person has been promoted at each stop. Despite the job changes, that is pretty impressive. Both employees mentioned above have the same level of experience. One seems like an ambitious, aggressive person. The other, may be a steadier contributor. Only you, as the manager, would know which is best for your particular opening.
TITLES AND COMPANY SIZE
This are very important factors, especially when considering a candidate from a smaller or larger employer. Here is an example:
A few years ago we had a Director of Operations job with a mid-sized (600 employee) client. It paid about 130k plus bonus. It was a nice job and had about 120 direct and indirect reports. One of the people we considered was a VP Operations at a 200 person company. Let’s call him Sam. Sam had the right background
and had about 100 direct and indirect reports. He looked good but our client’s HR Manager dismissed Sam because she said that Sam, with a VP Operations title, was a level above the position. She was solely focused on title and not the scope of responsibility. For Sam to move to a larger firm with a Director title was not a step down and it took a while to explain that but, she eventually agreed to see him. Sam did not get hired but was one of two finalists and gave our client a tough decision.
Titles only mean something in the context of company size. At the extreme, imagine a VP of HR at a 150 person company applying for the VP of HR job at GE. Those are two different jobs with the same title. It is a matter of scale.
Most people assume that it is easy to scale down and that the difficulty lies exclusively in scaling up from a smaller to larger employer. In my experience, that is not correct. Scaling down can be as tough as scaling up, especially if the person is not prepared for the personal and immediacy involved in managing at a smaller firm. At a large company, your authority comes from the title on your business card. At a smaller firm, your authority comes from what you say and how you say it. An executive with exclusively big company organizational management skills may flounder at a smaller firm that requires a more personal touch.
So, when considering titles, consider resources managed, not just titles. How many people does the person manage and what is the scale of the resources under his or her direction? Those are the important questions.
COMMUTE
We run into this a few times a year. In situations when we submit a resume for someone who will have a long commute (say an hour), we often get push back from our client. We used to have one client who insisted that anyone we submit be no more than 30 minutes away. That was an extreme example of the concern that companies have for employees, especially key employees, who face a long commute. Will they be distracted? Will they leave because of the commute? How will inclement weather affect them? Those are all valid concerns.
But, if there is one thing I have learned, it is that commutes are a very personal decision. Some people actually like a longer commute. It gives them time to unwind and think before they walk in the door. Optimal commute time is like chocolate and vanilla – a personal taste.
Here is a little technique to analyze commute times for a specific candidate. If the commute to your location is an hour, ask the following questions. Has the candidate ever commuted that far before? If yes, for how long? Have they ever left a job for a shorter commute or, conversely, for a longer commute? What type of commute was their hour – lots of traffic or lots of highway?
There is data in the details. Digging a little may help you make a more informed decision instead of a reflex.
In a perfect world, you should have some sense of who the candidate is BEFORE they walk in your door for an interview. That is what we do for clients here at Right Recruiting when we send interview notes to our clients with each resume submittal. If you make it a regular practice to sit and look at the context of a resume you will be more efficient in your interviewing time and make better hiring decisions.
Hopefully, as a manager or executive tasked with making sense of a resume for a key role, the info here can help you see the person and not just the paper. Employment is, after all, all about people.
As ever, thanks for getting this far and, as ever, remember Right Recruiting for all of your recruitment needs.
